Twilight Struggle

“Now the trumpet summons us again — not as a call to bear arms, though arms we need; not as a call to battle, though embattled we are — but a call to bear the burden of a long twilight struggle…”

– John F. Kennedy’s inaugural speech, 1961

He goes on to the bit about thinking not what your country can do for you but the idea of a twilight struggle is the most intriguing. It casts the whole sorry mess in a rather romantic light but it fits – conflicts playing out behind closed doors and in far-flung corners of the world – murky, secretive affairs… And so the designers of my new Cold War board game felt; the same quote opens their generous (32 page) rulebook. Its name? Twilight Struggle of course.

Board games have had a renaissance in recent years and a thriving sub-culture exists out of sight from ‘normal’ people. As such, there is a fair bit to catch up on. Firstly, they have not heard of any of the games anyone is playing. In fact, if they have heard of a game, we aren’t playing it. “I like Monopoly” someone offers plaintively – we don’t. “I love Cluedo” – kill yourself. “Risk is awesome!” – seriously, I would rather dine on my own head with a side of erm…your head than play Risk. I know this seems a little inconsistent – “but *sniff* you said you liked board games”. The thing is, it was a phoenix from the ashes style rebirth; the old, long, dull games died (in awesome Final Destination-ish ways) and a host of well-designed and imaginative games replaced them. If this is all news to you, go and play Catan but remember now you’ve heard of it, we don’t want to play it anymore. Sorry, I’ll be nice now.

Board Game Geek is the bible of this humble hobby and its games list, the gospel, with 57387 games by today’s count and since popular games have 20000+ votes, the rankings are pretty stable. New games are sometimes briefly overrated as everyone plays them for the first time but on the whole, it’s an accurate indication of quality. Imagine the excitement then, when it became clear that a game appeared to be bucking this trend and mounting a slow but steady climb up the list. Twilight Struggle now sits atop this list-y Olympus with statistical air between it and its nearest rival. “How does this happen?!” I hear you wail in anguished horror. No. Desperate curiosity? No. Faint interest? No answer. I’ll take that as a yes.

Twilight Struggle looks like a war game: big map, endless little counters, historical theme – your average board gamer assumed it was one step from battle re-enactments and gave it a wide berth but slowly its true colours were revealed. Now I would dearly love to tell you that when it was released, in 2005, I had the prescience to take a punt on it but I am an arriviste; I bought it when it reached number 1 and – no zealot like a convert – am atoning for my tardiness by proselytising here, there and everywhere (any excuse).

It’s a two player game, although I’ve played with teams of 3, which worked fine. You take control of the US or the USSR and you aim to earn influence around the world. You do this by playing cards which are all historical events or people, for example, playing the Che Guevara card will remove any US influence in Cuba and give the USSR enough influence to control it. Cards can also be played for their ‘operations points’, which allow you to simply add influence to any country you are connected to on the map or to stage coups in countries where your opponent has influence. Players aim to have enough influence in the world’s 6 regions to dominate or even control them, when their scoring card is played. Judicious scoring, winning the space race and satisfying your populace’s bloodlust without triggering nuclear war will see you win the war but if the game lasts all 10 turns you may not get much sleep. This is a long game. The really scary thing is I’m not sure I’d have it any other way. It’s just so fun, the time flies. My soviets finally eked out a very close victory on Saturday night after 9 hours and I loved every nail-biting minute of it. So sue me.

The reason Twilight Struggle is so engaging is because it creates the impression that the problems you are solving, the tools you are using and the way you are feeling is how it really was. I usually coo about clever mechanics, theme is bonus, but this game has opened my eyes to what is possible with some real attention to the source material. That’s not say it doesn’t have great mechanics, it absolutely does, but it also has cards that outline all the key events and people of the war and a rulebook which goes even further, giving a paragraph of historical context for every card.

But that’s the easy way to add theme – you write it on a card – the difficult bit and what the designers have done so well, is making the mechanics themselves reflect the theme, something Extra Credits is huge on. The mechanics are set up to create the same sorts of decisions that JFK had to make. They can tell some of the story by putting the player in classic Cold War situations. For example, you want to gain control of a country in Central America to establish a presence there – you must stage a coup to do so. Coups are easier to pull off in countries with a low ‘stability’ and the countries that fit the bill: Guatemala, Nicaragua and Haiti – sounds familiar right? Their stability is fixed and often, when you feel that you need to alter the balance of power in a region, you can only afford to target these unstable countries even though you know that your opponent will have little trouble reversing your actions. Its these mechanics, working as gameplay tools and as features of the Cold War theme, which make playing the game feel like leading a superpower through 30 years of…twilight struggle.

I used to think that board games were destined to continue as a thriving but perennial ‘sub-’ culture. I’m not so sure anymore. It’s a sign of the times that two successful video games writers have set up a board game internet show – Shut Up and Sit Down – and fantastic it is too. Twilight Struggle is proof that board games can continue to improve in pace with their computer-y cousins. They are similar enough that as video games grow, board games can piggy-back on their success snapping up gamers curious for a different experience. But they are also different enough to be an enjoyable counterpoint to what is largely a one-man-and-his-machine pastime. Or maybe we will see a fusion of board and video games – a board game controlled by software, which allows face-to-face play with a system more complex than two people could control. Iain M. Banks seems to think so. Personally, I’d be happy just to see more games like Twilight Struggle with all the mechanical elegance of a modern board game but also utterly immersed in a fascinating theme.

307 Comments

Filed under Game Design, Games, Reviews

307 Responses to Twilight Struggle

  1. Pingback: Biography is better | Jeremy Hogan

  2. Twilight Struggle | Jeremy Hogan
    bgyhkwnqo http://www.g6f231q0n234cqq6mfm4s3w79me18zq8s.org/
    [url=http://www.g6f231q0n234cqq6mfm4s3w79me18zq8s.org/]ubgyhkwnqo[/url]
    abgyhkwnqo

  3. As it can help them reach their accurate metabolic possibility, garcinia cambogia nutritional supplements should be taken by people with slow metabolism.

    • As always, it’s very important to let your
      physician know of any supplements you are taking when consulting with him about your weight reduction regimen.

  4. Vita Web does have a joint pain relief nutritional supplement that’s safe to take in combination with garcinia.

  5. Weight reduction can help lower your blood- blood pressure and
    glucose levels and enhance your blood-fat levels if they’re not in the healthy range.

  6. By the end of the 12 week period, the HCA group hadn’t exhibited a statistically significant difference in terms of percentage body fat reduction or weight reduction.

  7. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of
    any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically
    tweet my newest twitter updates. I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something
    like this. Please let me know if you run into anything.
    I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward
    to your new updates.

  8. Hi there, i read your blog from time to time and
    i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you
    get a lot of spam comments? If so how do you protect against it, any plugin or
    anything you can recommend? I get so much lately it’s driving me mad so any help is very much appreciated.

  9. This paragraph gives clear idea in support of the new viewers of blogging, that really
    how to do blogging and site-building.

  10. Hi would you mind sharing which blog platform
    you’re using? I’m planning to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a hard time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
    The reason I ask is because your design and style
    seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique.

    P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!

    • Halo Pak Reza, terima kasih atas hasil pemikiran yang dibagikan di mari. Berharap menjadi pengunjung setia di blog yang sangat keren ini.Saya adalah ’nubie’ yang ingin belajar tentang filsafat dan untuk sekarang ini tertarik untuk membaca tentang estetika dan moral. Saya ingin tahu beberapa filsuf serta materi yang Pak Reza saran dan rekomendasikan untuk belajar tentang subjek tersebut.Terima kasih

    • That’s a well-thought-out answer to a challenging question

    • Very cool info, though! Nice page thanks for the add!Oscar 2010 Dresses were amazing as always. Oscar’s colors are always rich; melon, teal,peridot mixed with white, blush , and black. Beading and embroidery twinkled every fancy, elegant Spanish Chantilly lace gowns.Zac Posen was sitting in the front row for the first time, seeing the spring summer 2010 collection of Oscar de la Renta. “It’s a dream to see the pinnacle of embroidery and luxurious fabrics from the best mills in the world.

  11. Hello my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, nice written and include approximately all important infos.
    I’d like to see extra posts like this .

  12. Jed

    Excellent blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
    I’m planning to start my own blog soon but
    I’m a little lost on everything. Would you recommend starting with a
    free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many options
    out there that I’m totally overwhelmed .. Any ideas?

    Many thanks!

  13. whoah this weblog is wonderful i love reading your articles.
    Keep up the good work! You already know, many people are looking round for this information, you could aid
    them greatly.

  14. The pitcher throws a baseball and whether by luck or by practice I manage to hit the ball.Scherzer is the first starting pitcher to start a season 12-0 since Roger Clemens did so in 1986. It wasn’t a prediction. Created upon Java system, it specials higher speeds and large amounts of overall flexibility.Article Source: ?Have you ever wondered why just before you get what you want things sort of go hay-wire? I’ve noticed that often, just when we think everything is finally about to come together, things just fall apart like crazy.Yesterday, we were playing 3-on-3 baseball.-No smoking or tobacco usage. Taped to your bathroom mirror, on your desk, beside your bed. “It’s time for us to get better.Scherzer is the first starting pitcher to start a season 12-0 since Roger Clemens did so in 1986.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  15. I enjoy you because of all of your effort on this web site. Ellie really likes engaging in investigation and it’s really easy to see why. All of us learn all about the lively means you provide useful steps through your website and in addition boost response from other ones on the content while our favorite princess is truly learning a lot. Have fun with the rest of the year. You’re the one conducting a fabulous job.

  16. My wife and i were cheerful when Louis could carry out his homework by way of the ideas he received in your blog. It’s not at all simplistic just to always be offering helpful hints which often other folks may have been making money from. And we fully grasp we need you to be grateful to for that. Those illustrations you’ve made, the simple site menu, the friendships you will make it possible to foster – it is many fabulous, and it’s really helping our son in addition to us understand this issue is enjoyable, and that is highly mandatory. Thank you for all!

  17. After research a few of the blog posts in your web site now, and I actually like your method of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website record and will probably be checking again soon. Pls try my website online as well and let me know what you think.

  18. Thank you a lot for providing individuals with such a spectacular possiblity to read critical reviews from this site. It’s usually very enjoyable and as well , stuffed with a great time for me personally and my office colleagues to visit the blog at minimum 3 times per week to learn the new items you have got. And definitely, we are at all times contented with the magnificent principles you give. Certain 1 ideas in this post are absolutely the most efficient I have had.

  19. Try not to use a lot of Flash in your internet site. You are required to evaluate the profitability score on a continual basis to confirm you are at the right track in connection to your online jewelry business. Socks peeking out of footwear or sandals is commonplace amid the kindergarten set.”They should absolutely make the deal,” one competing general manager opined about Farrell to Boston.Obtain further advice on water tank and the subject of water tanks. The upgrade of roofs is costly and can take a significant amount of time requiring suitable project planning, price comparisons, and the most reliable material.Your jewelry product descriptions should stand out from the page with vivid language and accurate details. Styles of Bowling Shoes » StrongPedia Article Directory – Free article directory. A water tank within a yuppie’s range of vision is intolerable. You might also buy a pouch for transporting the phone and a screen protector and case for regular use.

  20. http: teetoop. These shoes are primarily for professional bowlers. Usually, a water tank measures 12 feet in height, has a total volume capacity of 10000 gallons and is fixed on a 20foot steel frame. They can aid you figure out a design that functions for you given that they know the most about how you have dressed your while daily life. People are used to switching channels after midnight.comincorporate a minor black costume, a fitted jacket and matching skirt, a tailored pair of slacks in a neutral shade and a pair of dim, equipped trouser jeans.Obtain further advice on water tank and the subject of water tanks. Using no protection is an invitation for disaster because scratches will eventually happen.Time is money and your time is valuable. Typically, bowling shoes will range anywhere between $30 and $200 depending on what type of shoe you are looking for.
    Cheap Jerseys

  21. I needed to post you the very small note just to thank you again for the remarkable knowledge you’ve documented on this page. It has been certainly strangely generous of people like you to offer easily what a number of us could possibly have distributed for an e book to make some dough on their own, precisely since you might have done it in the event you desired. The guidelines likewise served to provide a good way to understand that other individuals have the identical zeal just like my own to find out much more with reference to this issue. Certainly there are a lot more pleasurable moments ahead for those who looked at your website.

  22. If you want in addition measurement Halloween costumes which are a lot more horror orientated, choose from Nightmare on Elm Street’s Miss Krueger or a Midnight Vampiress. 4) Be Very, Very Hard on YourselfPeople in the advertising world would literally sing the National Anthem of Kazakhstan naked in Grand Central Station during the height of rush hour for the next six to eight years for the opportunity to produce a Super Bowl ad.Naps will become less frequent throughout the day as well. While many sites that are great for into this category making the effort to force some product down your throat since they grant you random headlines and snippets to use “guru advice”, Affilorama actually delivers in terms of providing useful, relevant information for free.it has to feel big.

  23. S.”I heard from both Ned and Donnie saying they weren’t looking to trade me and the only way it happens is if a team blows them away (with an offer). In their storied history, theyve won three Stanley Cup Championships and 13 division championships.The Fire franchise experienced immediate success winning both the MLS Cup and the U.The third baseman has been sidelined with a hamstring injury since May.
    Wholesale Jerseys China

    • great post maria.i am completely 100000% jaded on the social media "scene" if i hear someone brag about their followers or digg votes or some other bullshit again i think i'll go insane. last refresh i had someone whom i had never heard of before come up to me and tell me how i should be helping him make us both money….wtf?please keep writing :-)

  24. Since this device will play a major role in our daily lives it is very important that we find ways to take care of the phone and make it last as long as possible. ABS plastic cases are inexpensive and very durable. However, it may simply be that they don’t want him going to the rival Red Sox. Use high quality content material to inspire these reliable, respected resources to need to feature a connect to your website independently. All that could be reused when you send out your own orders.Advertise on television channels after midnight.You can notify your pal about the most recent that you discovered about trend so that they know you are actually making an attempt to help out their picture. It will also need that you use significantly less of the product. Posting job listings and other relevant information within these publications is significant.1 trend idea to take into consideration is that it is a excellent concept to merge prints in a tasteful style.
    Wholesale Jerseys China

  25. My wife and i ended up being so relieved that Michael could deal with his basic research from your precious recommendations he grabbed from your very own web pages. It’s not at all simplistic to simply continually be offering secrets which people today have been selling. And we also remember we have got the website owner to give thanks to for this. The main explanations you’ve made, the straightforward site navigation, the relationships you give support to promote – it’s mostly impressive, and it’s helping our son and the family know that the matter is entertaining, which is certainly extraordinarily pressing. Thank you for the whole lot!